2012
CRIMINAL RULES SUGGESTIONS CHART
| 12-CR | NAME
OF INDIVIDUAL AND/OR ORGANIZATION | DATE
REC'D | RULE
OR FORM | STATUS |
| 12-CR-A | Hon. Christina Reiss | 2/14/12
| Rule 16(a) | Pending
consideration |
2011
CRIMINAL RULES SUGGESTIONS CHART
| 11-CR | NAME
OF INDIVIDUAL AND/OR ORGANIZATION | DATE
REC'D | RULE
OR FORM | STATUS |
| 11-CR-A | Professor
Carrie Leonetti | 06/13/11 | To
allow defenders to move for summary judgment | Pending
consideration |
| 11-CR-B | Hon. Robert E. Jones | 07/06/11
| Cost-containment Efforts of the Judiciary | Pending
consideration
|
| 11-CR-C | Hon. Eric H. Holder, Jr. | 10/20/11
| Rule 6(e) (amendment regarding historically significant grand jury material) | Suggestion acknowledged on 10/21/11; pending consideration by Advisory Committee on Criminal Rules
|
| 11-CR-D | Allison M. Zieve, Esq. ( Public Citizen Litigation Group) | 12/15/11
| Rule 6(e) | Pending
consideration
|
2010
CRIMINAL RULES SUGGESTIONS CHART
| 10-CR | NAME
OF INDIVIDUAL AND/OR ORGANIZATION | DATE
REC'D | RULE
OR FORM | STATUS |
| 10-CR-A | Department
of Justice (Hon. Lanny A. Breuer, Assistant
Attorney General) | 02/26/10 | Rules
5 and 58 | 04/10
– Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to Standing
Committee 06/10
– Standing Committee approved for publication for public comment 04/11
– Advisory Committee approved as published for submission to the Standing
Committee 06/11
– Standing Committee approved for submission to the Judicial Conference |
| 10-CR-B | Hon.
Harvey Schlesinger | 6/8/10 | Rule
17(a) | Pending
consideration |
| 10-CR-C | Eric
DeLeon | 6/24/10 | Rule
6 | Pending
consideration |
2009
CRIMINAL RULES SUGGESTIONS CHART
| 09-CR | NAME
OF INDIVIDUAL AND/OR ORGANIZATION | DATE
REC'D | RULE
OR FORM | STATUS |
| 09-CR-A | Hon.
Emmet G. Sullivan | 04/28/09 | Rule
16 | 10/09
– Advisory Committee considered and recommitted issue to Rule 16 subcommittee 04/10
– Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda 09/10
– Advisory Committee considered and recommitted to Rule 16 subcommittee 04/11
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take further action |
| 09-CR-B | Enoc Mendez | 06/02/09 | Rule
12 | 10/09
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 09-CR-C | Sharon Bush Ellison | 11/24/09 | Rules 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 | 04/10 – Advisory Committee
considered and declined to take action |
2008
CRIMINAL RULES SUGGESTIONS CHART
| 08-CR | NAME
OF INDIVIDUAL AND/OR ORGANIZATION | DATE
REC'D | RULE
OR FORM | STATUS |
| 08-CR-A | Judicial
Conference Committee on Criminal Law (Hon. Julie E. Carnes) | 06/24/08 | Rule
41 | 10/08
– Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda 04/09
– Advisory Committee considered and deferred pending study by the AO |
2007
CRIMINAL RULES SUGGESTIONS CHART
| 07-CR | NAME
OF INDIVIDUAL AND/OR ORGANIZATION | DATE
REC’D | RULE
OR FORM | STATUS |
| 07-CR-A | Hon.
Robert B. Collings | 04/24/07 | Rule
32 | 04/08
– Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to the Standing
Committee 06/08
– Standing Committee considered and approved for publication for public
comment 04/09
– Advisory Committee considered and approved as published for submission to
the Standing Committee 06/09
– Standing Committee approved for submission to the Judicial Conference 09/09
– Judicial Conference approved for submission to the Supreme Court 04/10
– Supreme Court promulgated |
| 07-CR-B | Magistrate Judges of the Eastern District of New York (Hon. Steven M. Gold) | 10/17/07 | Rule
4 Rule
41 | 10/08
– Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda 04/09
– Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to Standing
Committee 06/09
– Standing Committee approved for publication for public comment 04/10
– Advisory Committee approved for submission to Standing Committee 06/10
– Standing Committee approved for submission to Judicial Conference 09/10
– Judicial Conference approved for submission to the Supreme Court 04/11
– Supreme Court promulgated |
| 07-CR-C | Kelly
D. Warfield | 10/29/07 | AEDPA
Statute of Limitations | 04/08
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 07-CR-D | Stephen
P. Stoltz | 05/06/07 | Rule
45 | Pending
consideration |
| 07-CR-E | Hon.
Jack B. Weinstein | 06/03/07 | Rule
11 | 10/08
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
2006
CRIMINAL RULES SUGGESTIONS CHART
| 06-CR | NAME
OF INDIVIDUAL AND/OR ORGANIZATION | DATE
REC'D | RULE
OR FORM | STATUS |
| 06-CR-A | United
States Department of Justice (Benton J. Campbell) | 01/05/06 | Rule
Consistency with AEDPA Rule 11 | 04/06
– Advisory Committee appointed a subcommittee for study 10/06
– Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda for further
subcommittee study 04/07
– Advisory Committee considered and approved proposed amendments to Rule 11
for submission to the Standing Committee but did not approve proposed new
Rule 37 06/07
– Standing Committee approved proposed amendments to 11(a) for publication
for public comment and deferred publication of 11(b) 04/08
– Advisory Committee considered and approved 11(a) and 11(b) for submission
to the Standing Committee for republication as revised 06/08
– Standing Committee approved for submission to Judicial Conference 09/08
– Judicial Conference approved for submission to Supreme Court 03/09
– Supreme Court promulgated |
| 06-CR-B | United
States Department of Justice (Benton J. Campbell) | 01/05/06 | Rule
12 | 04/06
– Advisory Committee considered and tabled the suggestion until October 2006 10/06
– Advisory Committee tabled pending resolution of United States v. Resendiz-Ponce 04/07 – Advisory
Committee considered and retained on agenda 04/08 – Advisory
Committee considered and retained on agenda 10/08 – Advisory
Committee considered and retained on agenda 04/09
– Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to the Standing
Committee 06/09
– Standing Committee declined for publication and remanded to Advisory
Committee for further consideration 10/09
– Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda 04/10
– Advisory Committee considered and recommitted to Rule 12 subcommittee for
further consideration 09/10
– Advisory Committee considered, modified, and approved for submission to the
Standing Committee for republication 06/11
– Standing Committee approved for publication for public comment |
| 06-CR-C | United
States Department of Justice (Benton J. Campbell) | 01/05/06 | Rule
7 & 32.2 | 04/06
– Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda for further
subcommittee study 10/06
– Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda for further
subcommittee study 04/07
– Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to Standing
Committee 06/07
– Standing Committee approved for publication for public comment 04/08
– Advisory Committee considered, revised, and approved for submission to the
Standing Committee 06/08
– Standing Committee approved for submission to the Judicial Conference 09/08
– Judicial Conference approved for submission to Supreme Court 03/09
– Supreme Court promulgated |
| 06-CR-D | United
States Department of Justice (Benton J. Campbell) | 01/05/06 | Rule
41(b) | 04/06
– Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to Standing
Committee 06/06
– Standing Committee considered and approved for publication for public
comment 04/07
– Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to Standing
Committee with the bracketed exclusion of American Samoa (See suggestion
06-CR-G) 06/07
– Standing Committee approved for submission to the Judicial Conference 09/07
– Judicial Conference approved for submission to the Supreme Court 04/08
– Supreme Court promulgated |
| 06-CR-E | Hon.
Joel M. Flaum | 06/19/06 | Sealed
Cases | 10/06
– Referred to Committee on Court Administration and Case Management |
| 06-CR-F | Hon.
Anthony J. Battaglia | 08/15/06 | Rule
32.1 & 46 | 10/06
– Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda 04/07
– Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda 04/08
– Advisory Committee considered and deferred action for further study 10/07
– Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to Standing
Committee 06/08
– Standing Committee considered and approved for publication 04/09
– Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to Standing
Committee 06/09
– Standing Committee considered and approved for submission to the Judicial
Conference 09/09
– Judicial Conference considered and approved for submission to the Supreme
Court 04/10
– Supreme Court promulgated |
| 06-CR-G | Ninth
Circuit Judicial Council Pacific Islands Committee (Sally Pym) | 09/19/06 | Rule
41 | See
Suggestion 06-CR-D |
| 06-CR-H | Federal
Defender Sentencing Guideline Committee (Jon M. Sands) | 10/24/06 | Rule
32(h) | 10/08
– Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda for further study 04/09
– Advisory Committee considered and deferred consideration indefinitely due
to lack of consensus 10/09
– Advisory Committee considered and deferred indefinitely pending developing
federal sentencing law |
2005
CRIMINAL RULES SUGGESTIONS CHART
| 05-CR | NAME
OF INDIVIDUAL AND/OR ORGANIZATION | DATE
REC'D | RULE
OR FORM | STATUS |
| 05-CR-A 05-CR-A
(Addndm) | Professor
Linda A. Malone | 03/03/05 | Rules
4 & 5 (Vienna Convention) | 04/05
– Advisory Committee considered and tabled until next meeting 10/05
– Advisory Committee considered and tabled indefinitely See
suggestion 10-CR-A |
| 05-CR-B | James
E. Felman | 02/05 | Rules
16 & 32 | 04/05
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 05-CR-C | Hon.
James F. McClure, Jr. | 12/16/04 | Rule
10 Arraignment Procedures | 04/05
– Advisory Committee considered and tabled until next meeting 10/05
– Advisory committee considered and tabled indefinitely 04/08
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 05-CR-D | Hon.
Paul G. Cassell | 03/05 | Rule
Consistency with the Crime Victims Rights Act | 04/05
– Advisory Committee considered and appointed subcommittee for study 10/05
– Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to the Standing
Committee pending stylistic revisions 01/06
– Standing Committee approved for publication for public comment 04/07
– Advisory Committee considered, modified, and approved for submission to the
Standing Committee 06/07
– Standing Committee approved for submission to Judicial Conference 09/07
– Judicial Conference approved for submission to Supreme Court 04/08
– Supreme Court promulgated |
| 05-CR-E | Gregory
G. Skordas | 06/22/05 | Rule
17 (Crime Victims Rights Act) |
| 05-CR-F | Hon.
Michael M. Baylson | 11/02/05 | AEDPA/Habeas
Petitions | See
Suggestion 06-CR-A 04/08
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
2004
CRIMINAL RULES SUGGESTIONS CHART
| 04-CR | NAME
OF INDIVIDUAL AND/OR ORGANIZATION | DATE
REC'D | RULE
OR FORM | STATUS |
| 04-CR-A | Hon.
Robert B. Collings | 03/17/04 | Rule
16 | 05/04
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 04-CR-B | Hon.
James T. Trimble, Jr. | 04/07/04 | Rules
6 & 31 | 05/04
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 04-CR-C | Committee
on Court Administration and Case Management of the Judicial Conference of the
United States (Hon. John W. Lungstrum) | 08/02/04 | CM/ECF
– Mandatory Electronic Filing | 10/04
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
2003
CRIMINAL RULES SUGGESTIONS CHART
| 03-CR | NAME
OF INDIVIDUAL AND/OR ORGANIZATION | DATE
REC'D | RULE
OR FORM | STATUS |
| 03-CR-A | Hon.
Robert B. Collings | 01/24/03 | Rule
40 | 10/03
- Advisory Committee considered and designated a subcommittee for study 05/04
– Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to Standing
Committee 06/04
– Standing Committee approved for publication for public comment 04/05
– Advisory Committee approved for submission to the Standing Committee 06/05
– Standing Committee approved for submission to the Judicial Conference 09/05
– Judicial Conference approved for submission to the Supreme Court 04/06
– Supreme Court promulgated |
| 03-CR-B | Hon.
William F. Sanderson, Jr. | 03/04/03 | Rule
32.1 | 04/03
– Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda 10/03
– Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda 05/04
– Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to the Standing
Committee 06/04
– Standing Committee considered and approved for publication for public
comment 04/05
– Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to the Standing
Committee 06/05
– Standing Committee considered and approved for submission to Judicial
Conference 09/05
– Judicial Conference considered and approved for submission to the Supreme
Court 04/06
– Supreme Court promulgated |
| 03-CR-C | Carl
E. Person | 04/01/03 | Plea
Bargaining | 04/08
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 03-CR-D | Hon.
B. Janice Ellington | 07/24/03 | Rule
41 | 10/03
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 03-CR-E | Hon.
Gregory W. Carman | 10/27/03 | Rule
32 | 05/04
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 03-CR-F | Steve
Allen | 11/05/03 | Habeas
Corpus Rule 9 | 04/08
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 03-CR-G | Hon.
David D. Dowd, Jr. | 11/26/03 | Rule
11 | 05/04
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
2002
CRIMINAL RULES SUGGESTIONS CHART
| 02-CR | NAME
OF INDIVIDUAL AND/OR ORGANIZATION | DATE
REC'D | RULE
OR FORM | STATUS |
| 02-CR-A | Hon.
D. Brock Hornby | 03/15/02 | Rule
32 | 04/02
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 02-CR-B | Hon.
Paul L. Friedman | 04/02/02 | Rules
29, 33 & 34 | 04/03
– Advisory Committee considered and
approved for submission to Standing Committee 06/03
– Standing Committee approved for publication for public comment 05/04
– Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to Standing
Committee 06/04
– Standing Committee considered and approved for submission to Judicial
Conference 09/04
– Judicial Conference considered and approved for submission to the Supreme
Court 04/05
– Supreme Court promulgated |
| 02-CR-C | Hon.
David D. Dowd, Jr. | 06/05/02 | Rule
11 | 10/03
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 02-CR-D | Hon.
Ed Carnes | 04/15/02 | Rule
32 | 09/02
– Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda 04/03
– Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to Standing
Committee 06/03
– Standing Committee approved for publication for public comment 05/04
– Advisory Committee approved for submission to Standing Committee 06/04
– Standing Committee approved for submission to Judicial Conference 09/04
– Judicial Conference approved for submission to Supreme Court 04/05
– Supreme Court promulgated |
2001
CRIMINAL RULES SUGGESTIONS CHART
| 01-CR | NAME
OF INDIVIDUAL AND/OR ORGANIZATION | DATE
REC'D | RULE
OR FORM | STATUS |
| 01-CR-A | Hon.
Bernard Zimmerman | 01/29/01 | Rule
4 | 10/03
– Advisory Committee considered and designated a subcommittee for study 05/04
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 01-CR-B | American
Bar Association Governmental Affairs Office (Robert D. Evans) | 03/02/01 | Rule
6 & 35 | 10/03
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 01-CR-C | Richard
J. Douglas | 04/06/01 | Rule
11 | 04/03
– Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda 10/03
– Advisory Committee reconsidered and declined to take action 10/09
– Advisory Committee reconsidered and deferred pending a decision in Padilla v. Kentucky 04/10
– Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda, pending discussion of
Rule 11 Subcommittee 09/10
– Advisory Committee considered approved for submission to Standing Committee 01/11
– Standing Committee approved for publication for public comment |
| 01-CR-D | Carl
E. Person | 06/28/01 | Rule
16 | 04/02
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
2000
CRIMINAL RULES SUGGESTIONS CHART
| 00-CR | NAME
OF INDIVIDUAL AND/OR ORGANIZATION | DATE
REC'D | RULE
OR FORM | STATUS |
| 00-CR-A | 7th
Circuit Court of Appeals (Gino G. Agnello) | 04/11/00 | Rule
32 | 10/03
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 00-CR-B | Congressman
Jim Gibbons for Thomas Krummer | 03/21/00 | Rule
7 | 10/03
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 00-CR-C | Robert
L. Byer and David R. Fine | 08/15/00 | Criminal
Rules and Forms (AEDPA) | 04/01
– Advisory Committee considered and deferred pending subcommittee work 04/02
– Advisory Committee considered and approved recommendation |
| 00-CR-D | Jeremy
A. Bell | 11/20/00 | Rule
23 | 10/03
– Advisory Committee considered and declined to take action |
| 00-CR-E | Hon.
Tommy E. Miller | 12/11/00 | Rules
42 & 58 (Federal Courts Improvement Act) | 04/01
– Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to Standing
Committee as part of a “style package” 06/01
– Standing Committee approved style package for submission to Judicial
Conference 09/01
– Judicial Conference approved for submission to the Supreme Court 04/02
– Supreme Court promulgated |