2006 Criminal Rules Suggestions

06-CR

NAME OF INDIVIDUAL AND/OR ORGANIZATION

DATE REC'D

RULE OR FORM

STATUS

06-CR-A

United States Department of Justice (Benton J. Campbell)

01/05/06

Rule Consistency with AEDPA

Rule 11

04/06 – Advisory Committee appointed a subcommittee for study

10/06 – Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda for further subcommittee study

04/07 – Advisory Committee considered and approved proposed amendments to Rule 11 for submission to the Standing Committee but did not approve proposed new Rule 37

06/07 – Standing Committee approved proposed amendments to 11(a) for publication for public comment and deferred publication of 11(b)

04/08 – Advisory Committee considered and approved 11(a) and 11(b) for submission to the Standing Committee for republication as revised

06/08 – Standing Committee approved for submission to Judicial Conference

09/08 – Judicial Conference approved for submission to Supreme Court

03/09 – Supreme Court promulgated

06-CR-B

United States Department of Justice (Benton J. Campbell)

01/05/06

Rule 12

04/06 – Advisory Committee considered and tabled the suggestion until October 2006

10/06 – Advisory Committee tabled pending resolution of United States v. Resendiz-Ponce

04/07 – Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda

04/08 – Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda

10/08 – Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda

04/09 – Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to the Standing Committee

06/09 – Standing Committee declined for publication and remanded to Advisory Committee for further consideration

10/09 – Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda

04/10 – Advisory Committee considered and recommitted to Rule 12 subcommittee for further consideration

09/10 – Advisory Committee considered, modified, and approved for submission to the Standing Committee  for republication

06/11 – Standing Committee approved for publication for public comment

06-CR-C

United States Department of Justice (Benton J. Campbell)

01/05/06

Rule 7 & 32.2

04/06 – Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda for further subcommittee study

10/06 – Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda for further subcommittee study

04/07 – Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to Standing Committee

06/07 – Standing Committee approved for publication for public comment

04/08 – Advisory Committee considered, revised, and approved for submission to the Standing Committee

06/08 – Standing Committee approved for submission to the Judicial Conference

09/08 – Judicial Conference approved for submission to Supreme Court

03/09 – Supreme Court promulgated

06-CR-D

United States Department of Justice (Benton J. Campbell)

01/05/06

Rule 41(b)

04/06 – Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to Standing Committee

06/06 – Standing Committee considered and approved for publication for public comment

04/07 – Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to Standing Committee with the bracketed exclusion of American Samoa (See suggestion 06-CR-G)

06/07 – Standing Committee approved for submission to the Judicial Conference

09/07 – Judicial Conference approved for submission to the Supreme Court

04/08 – Supreme Court promulgated

06-CR-E

Hon. Joel M. Flaum

06/19/06

Sealed Cases

10/06 – Referred to Committee on Court Administration and Case Management

06-CR-F

Hon. Anthony J. Battaglia

08/15/06

Rule 32.1 & 46

10/06 – Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda

04/07 – Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda

04/08 – Advisory Committee considered and deferred action for further study

10/07 – Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to Standing Committee

06/08 – Standing Committee considered and approved for publication

04/09 – Advisory Committee considered and approved for submission to Standing Committee

06/09 – Standing Committee considered and approved for submission to the Judicial Conference

09/09 – Judicial Conference considered and approved for submission to the Supreme Court

04/10 – Supreme Court promulgated

06-CR-G

Ninth Circuit Judicial Council Pacific Islands Committee (Sally Pym)

09/19/06

Rule 41

See Suggestion 06-CR-D

06-CR-H

Federal Defender Sentencing Guideline Committee (Jon M. Sands)

10/24/06

Rule 32(h)

10/08 – Advisory Committee considered and retained on agenda for further study

04/09 – Advisory Committee considered and deferred consideration indefinitely due to lack of consensus

10/09 – Advisory Committee considered and deferred indefinitely pending developing federal sentencing law