Main content

Parma Community General Hospital v. Premiere Anesthesia of Parma, et al

Case Summary: 09-cv-00325

On December 31, 2008, plaintiff Parma Community General Hospital filed a complaint for breach of contract against defendant Premier Anesthesia of Parma in the Cuyahoga County, Ohio Court of Common Pleas, which was removed to the United States District Court for the Northern District of Ohio on the basis of federal diversity jurisdiction.  The complaint alleged that plaintiff and defendant entered into a contract for provision of anesthesia services at its hospital and that the contract was breached by defendant’s failure to provide plaintiff with full payment.  Defendant denied the allegations and filed a counterclaim for breach of contract against plaintiff, alleging that the hospital failed to comply with a binding settlement agreement.  Plaintiff later amended its claim to add a claim for fraudulent inducement of the settlement. 

A jury trial was held from August 2, 2011 through August 11, 2011.  The jury returned a verdict on August 12, 2011, finding in favor of plaintiff and in favor of defendant.  The jury awarded $0 in damages for both plaintiff and defendant.  The court entered judgment on August 15, 2011.

Case Highlights

  • Case removed from Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court on 2/11/2009
  • Jury Trial Held on 8/2/2011-8/12/2011
  • Jury verdict: [Doc ## 170-172]
    • Verdict for Parma Hospital on Breach of Anesthesiology Agreement Claim in amount of $0
    • Verdict for Premier Anesthesia on its Counter-claim of Breach of the Anesthesiology Agreement in the amount of $0
    • Verdict for Premier Anesthesia on its Counter-Claim of Breach of the Settlement Agreement in the amount of $0

Case-related documents, including those referenced above, are available via the Public Access to Court Electronic Records (PACER) service. For more information, visit Pacer.gov.

Videos from this Case:

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 1)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 1)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 8:30 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 2)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 2)

Parma Community General Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia of Parma et al (Part 2) Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 3)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 3)

Parma Community General Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia of Parma et al (Part 3) Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 4)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 4)

Parma Community General Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia of Parma et al (Part 4) Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 5)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 5)

Parma Community General Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia of Parma et al (Part 5) Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 6)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 6)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 8:30 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 7)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 7)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 8:30 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 8)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 8)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 8:30 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 9)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 9)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 8:30 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding. Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 10)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 10)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 8:30 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 11)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 11)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 8:30 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 12)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 12)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 9:01 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 13)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 13)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 8:30 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 14)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 14)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 10:31 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 15)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 15)

Parma Community General Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia of Parma et al (Part 15) Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 3:22 PM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 16)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 16)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 8:31 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 17)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 17)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 9:52 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 18)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 18)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 10:44 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 19)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 19)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 1:50 PM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 20)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 20)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 3:45 PM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 21)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 21)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 4:00 PM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 22)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 22)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 8:35 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 23)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 23)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 10:15 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 24)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 24)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 2:10 PM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 25)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 25)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 8:45 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 26)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 26)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 10:26 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 27)
Thumbnail for OHN- Parma Hospital v. Premier Anesthesia (Part 27)

Case: 1:09-cv-00325-DCN, Jury trial, 11:50 AM (CDT) in the Carl B. Stokes U.S. Court House in Cleveland, Ohio. Judge Donald C. Nugent presiding.


Click to Play Video