2003 APPELLATE RULES COMMENTS CHART

03-AP

NAME OF INDIVIDUAL AND/OR ORGANIZATION

DATE REC’D

RULE

DATE RESP

03-AP-001

Veronica L. Duffy, Esq.

9/2

32.1

9/26

03-AP-002

Mark Arnold, Esq.

9/2

32.1

9/26

03-AP-003

Request to Testify 1/26/04

Steven I. Wallach, Esq.

9/2

All

9/26

03-AP-004

Daniel E. Mitchel, Reference Librarian

9/3

32.1

9/26

03-AP-005

David J. Weimer, Esq.

9/5

32.1

9/26

03-AP-006

James B. Friderici, Esq.

9/9

32.1

9/26

03-AP-007

Prof. Philip A. Pucillo

9/29

4

 

03-AP-008 Request to testify 1/26/04

Public Citizen Litigation Group (Brian Wolfman)

10/15


2/24/04

All (specifically 35, 27, 28.1)

Addendum

 

03-AP-009

Judge Michael Boudin

10/17

35

 

03-AP-010

Judge David M. Ebel

10/17

32.1

 

03-AP-011 (Also

03-BK-001 03-CV-002

03-CR-002)

Jack E. Horsley, J.D.

10/17

All (specifically

4, 27)

 

03-AP-012

Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson III

10/20

35

 

03-AP-013

Judge William W. Wilkins

10/21

35

 

03-AP-014 (Also

03-CV-004)

Paul McNeill, Esq.

10/21

All

 

03-AP-015

Robert N. Markle, Esq.

10/29

32.1

 

03-AP-016

Philip Allen Lacovara, Esq.

11/3

All (specifically 4, 28.1, 32.1, 35)

 

03-AP-017

J. Craig Williams, Esq.

11/29

32.1

 

03-AP-018

Gayle D. Gunkut

11/29

32.1

 

03-AP-019

Judge John A. Darden

12/1

32.1

 

03-AP-020

Christopher A. Newman, Esq.

12/5

32.1

 

03-AP-021

Prof. Brian Bix

12/8

32.1

 

03-AP-022

Amir Weinberg, Esq.

12/8

32.1

 

03-AP-023

Elia Weinbach, Esq.

12/8

32.1

 

03-AP-024

Gail S. Coleman, Esq.

12/8

32.1

 

03-AP-025

Eric C. Liebeler, Esq.

12/9

32.1

 

03-AP-026

Judge Alfred T. Goodwin

12/9

32.1

 

03-AP-027

Deval L. Patrick

12/9

32.1

 

03-AP-028

Marc S. Mayerson, Esq.

12/9

32.1

 

03-AP-029

Prof. Michele Landis Dauber

12/9

32.1

 

03-AP-030

Benjamin I. Sachs, Esq.

12/9

32.1

 

03-AP-031

Robert Sargent Shriver III

12/9

32.1

 

03-AP-032

Request to Testify 1/20/04

Prof. Stephen R. Barnett

12/10

1/7/04


1/7/04


2/18/04

32.1

Addendum 1: Article

Addendum 2:

Article

Addendum 3:

Comments

 

03-AP-033

Chris Sprigman

12/11

32.1

 

03-AP-034

Steven Wyner, Esq.

12/11

32.1

 

03-AP-035

Request to Testify 1/26/04

Jessie Allen, on behalf of the Brennan Center for Justice at NYU School of Law

12/12

32.1

 

03-AP-036

Robert H. Rotstein, Esq.

12/12

32.1

 

03-AP-037

Christopher Hays, Esq.

12/12

32.1

 

03-AP-038

Hon. NA “Tito” Gonzales (State Court Judge)

12/12

32.1

 

03-AP-039

James M. Rockett, Esq.

12/12

32.1

 

03-AP-040

John P. Cardosi, Esq.

12/12

32.1

 

03-AP-041

Bartko, Zankel, Tarrant & Miller (Martin Zankel, Esq.)

12/12

32.1

 

03-AP-042

Kathryn E. Dobel, Esq.

12/12

32.1

 

03-AP-043

Theresa Trzaskoma

12/14

32.1

 

03-AP-044

Cheryl L. Kopitzke, Esq.

12/15

32.1

 

03-AP-045

Prof. Daniel P. Tokaji

12/22

32.1

 

03-AP-046

Judge Robert Boochever

12/15

32.1

 

03-AP-047

Judge Myron H. Bright

12/16

32.1

 

03-AP-048

Justice Maria P. Rivera

12/16

32.1

 

03-AP-049

Gregory S. Fisher, Esq.

12/16

32.1

 

03-AP-050

Bernard J. Allard, Esq.

12/17

32.1

 

03-AP-051

Guy W. Stilson, Esq.

12/17

32.1

 

03-AP-052

Judge John T. Noonan, Jr.

12/22

32.1

 

03-AP-053

David S. Gould, Esq.

12/17

32.1

 

03-AP-054

Judge Robert W. Gettleman

12/18

32.1

 

03-AP-055

John Trasvina, Esq.

12/18

32.1

 

03-AP-056

Judge Pat Williams

12/19

32.1

 

03-AP-057

Benedon & Serlin (Gerald Serlin, Esq.)

12/19

32.1

 

03-AP-058

Marc Bond, Assistant Counsel, Union Oil Company of California

12/19

32.1

 

03-AP-059

Judge William A. Fletcher

12/22

32.1

 

03-AP-060

Arthur Fine, Esq., and Douglas W. Bordewieck, Esq.

12/22

32.1

 

03-AP-061

Judge Ferdinand F. Fernandez

12/22

32.1

 

03-AP-062

Prof. Victor Fleischer

12/23

32.1

 

03-AP-063

Judge Procter Hug, Jr.

12/23

32.1

 

03-AP-064

Paul T. Cappuccio

12/23

32.1

 

03-AP-065

Judge William W Schwarzer

12/23

32.1

 

03-AP-066

Judge Milton I. Shadur

12/23

32.1

 

03-AP-067

Judge Thomas G. Nelson

12/24

32.1

 

03-AP-068

Judge Ralph Adam Fine (Wisconsin Court of Appeals)

12/29

32.1

 

03-AP-069

Request to Testify 1/26/04

American Bar Association Section of Litigation (Judah Best, Of Counsel)

12/29

32.1

 

03-AP-070

Mark B. Jacobs, Esq.

12/29

32.1

 

03-AP-071

Robert Bstart

12/29

4

 

03-AP-072

Prof. Stuart Banner

12/30

32.1

 

03-AP-073

Lawrence J. Siskind, Esq.

12/30

32.1

 

03-AP-074

Judge Geraldine Mund

12/30

32.1

 

03-AP-075

Judge Barry D. Silverman

12/30

32.1

 

03-AP-076

Judge James R. Browning

12/30

32.1

 

03-AP-077

Judge Joseph T. Sneed

12/30

32.1

 

03-AP-078

Prof. Jerry L. Anderson

12/30

32.1

 

03-AP-079

Brendon & Serlin (Gerald Serlin, Esq.)

12/30

32.1

 

03-AP-080

Derek L. Shaffer, Esq.

12/30

32.1

 

03-AP-081

Judge Richard T. Tallman

12/30

32.1

 

03-AP-082

Judge J. Clifford Wallace

12/30

32.1

 

03-AP-083

Request to Testify 1/26/04

American College of Trial Lawyers (William T. Hangley, Esq.)

12/30

32.1

 

03-AP-084

Kenneth N. Klee, Esq.

1/5/04

32.1

 

03-AP-085

Sandra S. Ikuta, Esq.

1/5/04

32.1

 

03-AP-086

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (Judge Haldane Robert Mayer)

1/6/04

32.1, 35, 28

 

03-AP-087

Sheryl Musgrove, Esq.

1/6/04

32.1

 

03-AP-088

Homan Taghdiri

1/6/04

32.1

 

03-AP-089

Farahnaz Nourmand

1/7/04

32.1

 

03-AP-090

Gabriel A. Espinosa

1/6/04

32.1

 

03-AP-091

Prof. Richard W. Painter

1/6/04

32.1

 

03-AP-092

Robert E. Toone, Esq.

1/7/04

32.1

 

03-AP-093

Prof. Michael S. Knoll

1/9/04

32.1

 

03-AP-094

Judge William A. Norris

1/8/04

32.1

 

03-AP-095

Robert K. Niewijk, Esq.

1/9/04

32.1

 

03-AP-096

Brian J. Murray, Esq.

1/12/04

32.1

 

03-AP-097

New York State Bar Association’s Committee on Courts of Appellate Jurisdiction (Mr. Jean E. Nelson)

1/12/04

32.1

 

03-AP-098

Robert A. Merring, Esq.

1/12/04

32.1

 

03-AP-099

Charles M. Sevilla., Esq.

1/12/04

32.1

 

03-AP-100

Prof. George M. Strickler

1/16/04

32.1

 

03-AP-101

Stephen A. Kroft, Esq.

1/13/04

32.1

 

03-AP-102

Rachelle D. Barbour

1/13/04

32.1

 

03-AP-103

Ellis J. Horvitz, Esq.

1/13/04

2/26/04

32.1

Addendum

 

03-AP-104

Brian T. Fitzpatrick, Esq.

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-105

Daniel B. Levin, Esq.

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-106

Hon. Shirley M. Hufstedler

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-107

P. Cameron DeVore, Esq.

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-108

John Vaughan, Esq.

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-109

Michael D. Young, Esq.

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-110

Hon. William C. Canby, Jr.

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-111

Stewart A. Baker, Esq.

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-112

Irell & Manella LLP (Richard H. Borow, Esq.)

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-113

Paul J. Watford, Esq.

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-114

Matthew C. Winter

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-115

Michelle Villasenor-Grant

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-116

Sylvia Royce

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-117

Richard H. Rosenberg, Esq.

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-118

Roberta Gonzalez

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-119

Mark B. Weintraub

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-120

James R. Edwards, Esq.

1/14/04

32.1

 

03-AP-121

Josh Goldfoot, Esq.

1/15/04

32.1

 

03-AP-122

Matthew J. Sanders, Esq.

1/15/04

27

 

03-AP-123

Don Willenburg, Esq.

1/15/04

32.1

 

03-AP-124

Samuel Richard Rubin, Esq.

1/16/04

32.1

 

03-AP-125

Richard Crane, Esq.

1/16/04

32.1

 

03-AP-126

Hon. Richard C. Neal

1/16/04

32.1

 

03-AP-127

Rosetta Shatkin

1/19/04

32.1

 

03-AP-128

H. Joseph Nourmand, Esq.

1/16/04

32.1

 

03-AP-129

Judge Stephen S. Trott

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-130

Judge Carlos Tiburcio Bea

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-131

Judge Dorothy W. Nelson

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-132

Judge Kim McLane Wardlaw

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-133

Judge Cynthia Holcomb Hall

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-134

Judge Marsha S. Berzon

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-135

Judge Otto R. Skopil, Jr.

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-136

Judge Virginia A. Mathis

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-137

Judge Jane A. Restani

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-138

Andrew K. Nietor, Esq.

1/23/04

32.1

 

03-AP-139

James H. Locklin, Esq.

1/23/04

32.1

 

03-AP-140

Thomas F. Tait, Esq.

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-141

Theodore J. Kozloff, Esq.

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-142

Michael Barclay, Esq.

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-143

Mark Kerslake

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-144

Joseph W. Cotchett, Esq., Nancy L. Fineman, Esq., Elizabeth C. Pritzker, Esq., Laura E. Schlichtmann, Esq., Bruce L. Simon, Esq., Steven N. Williams, Esq., and Robrt G. Retana, Esq.,

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-145

Jeffrey B. Coyne, Esq.

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-146

Jonathan A. Loeb, Esq.

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-147

Marwit Capital (Chris L. Britt, President)

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-148

Sandberg Furniture (John A. Sandberg, President)

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-149

Craig Rosler, Esq.

1/23/04

32.1

 

03-AP-150

Lisa Perrochet, Esq.

1/20/04

2/5/04

32.1

Addendum

 

03-AP-151

Jerome B. Falk, Jr., Esq.

1/20/04

32.1

 

030AP-152

Nicole C. Hancock, Esq.

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-153

Prof. Mark Lemley

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-154

Martha M. Hall, Esq.

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-155

Judge Robert K. Puglia (State of California Appellate Judge, Retired)

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-156

Judge Jerome Farris

1/21/04

32.1

 

03-AP-157

Gregory T.H. Lee, Esq.

1/21/04

32.1

 

03-AP-158

Prof. Eugene Volokh

1/21/04

32.1

 

03-AP-159

Allison Claire, Esq.

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-160

Lara A. Bazelon, Esq.

1/22/04

32.1

 

03-AP-161

Leslie A. Hakala, Esq.

1/22/04

32.1

 

03-AP-162

Davina T. Chen, Esq.

1/22/04

32.1

 

03-AP-163

Carole Tkacz

1/22/04

32.1

 

03-AP-164

William A. Burck, Esq.

1/22/04

32.1

 

03-AP-165

Monica Knox, Esq.

1/22/04

32.1

 

03-AP-166

Marcy J. Tiffany, Esq.

1/23/04

32.1

 

03-AP-167

Judge Warren J. Ferguson

1/23/04

32.1

 

03-AP-168

Mary E. Kelly, Esq.

1/23/04

32.1

 

03-AP-169

Judge Alex Kozinski

1/20/04

32.1

 

03-AP-170

Judge Thomas M. Reavley

1/28/04

32.1

 

03-AP-171

Karyn H. Bucur, Esq.

1/26/04

32.1

 

03-AP-172

Carlton F. Gunn, Esq.

1/26/04

31.1

 

03-AP-173

Kurt D. Hermansen, Esq.

1/26/04

32.1

 

03-AP-174

Judge Vincent P. Zurzolo, Central District CA Bankruptcy Judge

1/26/04

32.1

 

03-AP-175

Knut S. Johnson, Esq.

1/26/04

32.1

 

03-AP-176

Donald S. Frick, Esq.

1/26/04

32.1

 

03-AP-177

Kara B. Persson, Esq.

1/26/04

32.1

 

03-AP-178

Gregory Nicolaysen, Esq.

1/26/04

32.1

 

03-AP-179

Evan A. Jenness, Esq.

1/26/04

32.1

 

03-AP-180

W. John Thiel, Esq.

1/26/04

32.1

 

03-AP-181

Diane M. Regan, Esq.

1/27/04

32.1

 

03-AP-182

(repeat of Hermansen173)

 

 

 

03-AP-183

Gretchen Fusilier, Esq.

1/27/04

32.1

 

03-AP-184

Chase A. Scolnick, Esq.

1/27/04

32.1

 

03-AP-185

Donna Bader, Esq.

1/27/04

32.1

 

03-AP-186

Harvey I. Saferstein, Esq.

1/27/04

32.1

 

03-AP-187

Justin Farar, Esq.

1/27/04

32.1

 

03-AP-188

W. Dea Montague, Esq.

1/27/04

32.1

 

03-AP-189

Bethany L. O’Neill

1/27/04

32.1

 

03-AP-190

Timothy A. Scott, Esq.

1/27/04

32.1

 

03-AP-191

Jerald L. Brainin, Esq.

1/27/04

32.1

 

03-AP-192

Judge Michael Boudin

1/28/04

32.1, 35

 

03-AP-193

W.F. Rylaarsdam, Associate Justice, CA Court of Appeal

1/28/04

32.1

 

03-AP-194

Craig Wilkie, Esq.

1/28/04

32.1

 

03-AP-195

Myra Sun, Esq.

1/28/04

32.1

 

03-AP-196

Richard D. Marks, Esq.

1/28/04

32.1

 

03-AP-197

Mark S. Pulliam, Esq.

1/28/04

32.1

 

03-AP-198

Prof. Ethan Stone

1/28/04

32.1

 

03-AP-199

Michael Tanaka, Esq.

1/28/04

32.1

 

03-AP-200

Michael A. Brodsky, Esq.

1/28/04

32.1

 

03-AP-201

Los Angeles County Bar Asociation Appellate Courts Committee (James S. Link, Esq.)

1/28/04

4, 27, 28.1, 35, 32.1

 

03-AP-202

Hayward J. Kaiser

1/28/04

32.1

 

03-AP-203

Patricia Lofton, Esq.

1/28/04

32.1

 

03-AP-204

David M. Luboff, Esq.

1/29/04

32.1

 

03-AP-205

Hartwell V. Harris, law student

1/29/04

32.1

 

03-AP-206

Dr. Philip K. Anthony

1/29/04

32, 32.1

 

03-AP-207

Michael E. Lopez, Esq.

1/29/04

32.1

 

03-AP-208

Jonathan M. Shaw, Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-209

Kerry Hubers, Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-210

Steven R. Minor, Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-211

J. Christopher Desmond, Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-212

Hugh R. Law, Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-213

Robert Don Gifford

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-214

Charles E. Young, Jr., Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-215

Michael Bergfeld, Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-216

Stephen Marsh, Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-217

Samuel M. Ventola, Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-218

Stephen C. Neal, Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-219

Prof. Andrew M. Siegel

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-220

David C. Pauling, Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-221

Ward Farnsworth, Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-222

James B. Morse, Jr.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-223

David R. Fine, Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-224

Victor H. Woodworth, Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-225

Ashley Doherty

1/30/04

3/1/04

32.1

Addendum

 

03-AP-226

John M. Nettleton,, Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-227

David W. Floren, Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-228

Charles M. Miller, Esq.

1/30/04

32.1

 

03-AP-229

Arlus J. Stephens, Esq.

2/2/04

32.1

 

03-AP-230

Roy M. Jessee, Esq.

2/2/04

32.1

 

03-AP-231

Damon A. Katz

2/2/04

32.1

 

03-AP-232

John A. Taylor, Jr., Esq.

2/2/04

32.1

 

03-AP-233

Judge Pamela Ann Rymer

2/2/04

32.1

 

03-AP-234

Stephen Yagman, Esq.

2/2/04

32.1

 

03-AP-235

ACLU Foundation of Southern California (Peter Eliasberg, Managing Attorney)

2/2/04

32.1

 

03-AP-236

Jana L. Torok

2/2/04

32.1

 

03-AP-237

Mary French

2/2/04

32.1

 

03-AP-238

Nom. D. Plume

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-239

Kenneth J. Schmier, Esq.

2/3/04

2/6/04

32.1

Addendum

 

03-AP-240

Bruce Livingston, Esq.

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-241

Katherine Kimball Windsor

2/2/04

32.1

 

03-AP-242

John J. Cleary, Esq.

2/2/04

32.1

 

03-AP-243

William T. Rintala, Esq.

2/2/04

32.1

 

03-AP-244

Fred H. Altshuler, Esq.

2/2/04

32.1

 

03-AP-245

Sean W. Gallagher, Esq.

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-246

Judy Clarke, Esq.

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-247

Karen L. Landau, Esq.

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-248

Oswald Parada, Esq.

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-249

Christopher R.J. Pace, Esq.

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-250

Judge David Alan Ezra

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-251

Hoyt Y. Sze, Esq.

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-252

Judge John E. Ryan

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-253

Vince G. Chhabria, Esq.

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-254

Danny Chou, Esq.

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-255

Raoul D. Kennedy, Esq.

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-256

Michael Garcia, Esq.

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-257

Susan Lew, Esq.

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-258

Mark Ouweleen, Esq.

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-259

J. Al Latham, Jr., Esq.

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-260

James Stern, Esq.

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-261

John P. Frantz, Esq.

2/3/04

32.1

 

03-AP-262

Eric H. Joss, Esq.

2/4/04

32.1

 

03-AP-263

Paul Grossman, Esq.

2/4/04

32.1

 

03-AP-264

Douglas Feick, Esq.

2/4/04

32.1

 

03-AP-265

Jacob Aftergood

2/4/04

32.1

 

03-AP-266

Fred H. Bartlit, Jr., Esq.

2/4/04

32.1

 

03-AP-267

Stephen P. Berzon, Esq.

2/4/04

32.1

 

03-AP-268

California La Raza Lawyers Association

(Luis J. Rodriguez, Pres.)

2/4/04

32.1