2008 CIVIL RULES COMMENTS CHART

DOCKET NUMBER	CROSS REFERENCE	NAME OF INDIVIDUAL AND/OR ORGANIZATION	DATE REC'D	RULE	DATE RESP
08-CV-001	08-CV-046 Testimony	Center for Constitutional Litigation (John Vail) Request to Testify - DC	9/9/08	56	10/16/08
08-CV-002	08-CV-047 Testimony	Edward J. Brunet Request to Testify - DC	9/23/08	56	10/16/08
08-CV-003		Leslie R. Weatherhead	9/24/08	26 & 56	10/16/08
08-CV-004 08-AP-001		Benjamin J. Butts	9/22/08	CV & AP	10/16/08
08-CV-005		Edmund Scientific Company (Norman W. Edmund)	9/24/08	26	10/16/08
08-CV-006		Honorable Avern Cohn	10/1/08	56	10/16/08
08-CV-007		William M. Griffin, III	9/29/08	26	10/16/08
08-CV-008		Kenneth A. Lazarus	9/29/08	26 & 56	10/16/08
08-CV-009		Honorable G. Patrick Murphy	10/6/08	56	10/16/08
08-CV-010		Scott A. Kreider	10/7/08	56	10/16/08
08-CV-011		Robert B. Anderson	9/29/08	56	10/16/08
08-CV-012	08-CV-049 Testimony	Elizabeth M. Schneider Request to Testify - DC	10/10/08	56	10/10/08
08-CV-013		Alfred W. Cortese, Jr. Request to Testify - DC	10/10/08	26 & 56	10/16/08
08-CV-014		Honorable Ortrie D. Smith	10/16/08	56	10/16/08
08-CV-015	08-CV-050 Testimony	Stephen G. Morrison Request to Testify - DC	10/15/08	26 & 56	10/16/08
08-CV-016		Joseph D. Garrison	10/15/08	56	10/16/08
08-CV-017		Honorable John W. Sedwick	10/15/08	56	10/16/08
08-CV-018	08-CV-044 Testimony	Claudia McCarron Request to Testify - DC	10/15/08	56	10/16/08
08-CV-019	08-CV-124 Testimony	Federation of Defense and Corporate Counsel (Wayne B. Mason) Request to Testify –San Antonio	10/16/08	26 & 56	10/17/08
08-CV-020		Honorable Joseph M. Hood	10/16/08	56	10/17/08
08-CV-021	08-CV-057 Testimony	R. Matthew Cairns Request to Testify - DC	10/16/08	26 & 56	10/17/08
08-CV-022	08-CV-066 Testimony	Richard T. Seymour Request to Testify -DC	10/17/08	56	10/20/08
08-CV-023		Verizon Wireless (Robert L. Ernst) Request to Testify - DC	10/17/08	56	10/20/08
08-CV-024	08-CV-048 Testimony	Metropolitan Washington Employment Lawyers Association and/or Stephen Z. Chertkof Request to Testify - DC	10/17/08	56	10/20/08
08-CV-025		The Voice of the Defense Bar (Marc E. Williams) Request to Testify -DC	10/20/08	26 & 56	10/20/08
08-CV-026	08-CV-052 Testimony	Center for Constitutional Litigation (Stephen B. Pershing) Request to Testify - DC	10/19/08	26	10/23/08
08-CV-027		Michael R. Nelson Request to Testify – San Antonio	10/23/08	56	10/23/08
08-CV-028		Honorable H. Russel Holland	10/23/08	56	10/28/08
08-CV-029		Bruce R. Parker Request to Testify - DC	10/24/08	26 & 56	10/28/08
08-CV-030		Honorable Graham C. Mullen	10/27/08	56	10/28/08
08-CV-031	08-CV-045 Testimony	Debra Tedeschi Herron Request to Testify - DC	10/27/08	26 & 56	10/28/08
08-CV-032		Michael R. Nelson Request to Testify - DC	10/27/08	56	10/28/08
08-CV-033		Honorable Inge Prytz Johnson	10/29/08	56	10/30/08
08-CV-034	08-CV-051 Testimony	Latha Raghavan Request to Testify - DC	10/30/08	26 & 56	10/31/08
08-CV-035	08-CV-040 Testimony	Johnson & Johnson (Theodore Van Itallie) Request to Testify - DC	10/30/2008	26 & 56	11/3/08
08-CV-036		Institute for Legal Reform, US Chamber of Commerce (Thomas A. Gottschalk) Request to Testify - DC	10/30/08	56	11/3/08
08-CV-037		Adam N. Steinman	11/3/08	56	11/3/08
08-CV-038		The Council of the Section of Litigation, ABA (Robert L. Rothman)	11/3/08	26	11/3/08
08-CV-039		Alan B. Morrison	11/3/08	56	11/4/08
08-CV-040	08-CV-035 Request	Johnson & Johnson (Theodore Van Itallie)	11/10/08	26 & 56
08-CV-041		Patrick Allen	11/10/08	26	11/10/08
08-CV-042		Honorable Robert G. Doumar	11/10/08	56	11/10/08
08-CV-043	08-CV-148 Request	Honorable David C. Norton	11/10/08	56	11/10/08
08-CV-044	08-CV-018 Request	Claudia D. McCarron	11/10/08	56
08-CV-045	08-CV-031 Request	Debra Tedeschi Herron	11/10/08	26 & 56
08-CV-046	08-CV-001 Request	Center for Constitutional Litigation (John Vail)	11/10/08	56
08-CV-047	08-CV-002 Request	Northwestern School of Law of Lewis & Clark College Edward Brunet)		56
08-CV-048	08-CV-024 Request	Metropolitan Washington Employment Lawyers Association and/or Stephen Z. Chertkof	11/12/08	56
08-CV-049	08-CV-012 Request	Elizabeth M. Schneider	11/12/08	56
08-CV-050	08-CV-015 Request	Stephen G. Morrison	11/12/08	26 & 56
08-CV-051	08-CV-034 Request	Latha Raghavan	11/12/08	26 & 56
08-CV-052	08-CV-026 Request	Center for Constitutional Litigation (Stephen B. Pershing)	11/10/08	26
08-CV-053		Honorable Benson Everett Legg	11/13/08	56	11/14/08
08-CV-054		Joseph D. Garrison Request to Testify - DC	11/13/08	56
08-CV-055		Gregory P. Joseph	11/17/08	26 &56	11/21/08
08-CV-056		Honorable Frank H. Easterbrook	11/17/08	26 & 56	11/21/08
08-CV-057	08-CV-021 Request	R. Matthew Cairns	11/17/08	26 & 56
08-CV-058	08-CV-113 Testimony	John H. Martin Request to Testify – San Antonio	11/18/08	26 & 56	11/21/08
08-CV-059		Sarah E. Iiams Request to Testify – San Antonio - CANCELLED	11/19/08	56	11/21/08
08-CV-060		American College of Trial Lawyers – Federal Civil Rules Committee (Chris Kitchel)	11/10/08	26 & 56	11/21/08
08-CV-061		Lawyers for Civil Justice and U. S. Chamber Institute for Legal Reform	11/12/08	26 & 56	11/21/08
08-CV-062		Honorable Roger L. Hunt	11/13/08	56	11/21/08
08-CV-063	08-CV-139 Testimony	Voice of the Defense Bar (Kimberly D. Baker) Request to Testify – San Francisco	11/20/08	26 & 56	11/21/08
08-CV-064		Honorable James C. Fox	11/20/08	56	11/21/08
08-CV-065	08-CV-110 Testimony	Shell Oil Company (G. Edward Pickle) Request to Testify – San Antonio	11/21/08	26 & 56	11/21/08
08-CV-066	08-CV-022 Request	Richard T. Seymour	11/17/08	56
08-CV-067	08-CV-144 Testimony	Ralph A. Zappala Request to Testify – San Francisco	11/25/08	26 & 56	11/26/08
08-CV-068	08-CV-129 Testimony	Daniel J. Herling Request to Testify – San Francisco	12/01/08	26 & 56	12/02/08
08-CV-069		Honorable Robert S. Lasnik Request to Testify – San Francisco	12/01/08	56	12/02/08
08-CV-070		Law Professors (John Leubsdorf & William H. Simon)	12/01/08	56	12/02/08
08-CV-071		Honorable Paul J. Kelly, Jr.	12/01/08	56	12/02/08
08-CV-072		Federal Practitioners	12/01/08	56	12/02/08
08-CV-073		Thomas A. Packer Request to Testify – San Francisco	12/01/08	26 & 56	12/02/08
08-CV-074		Marc A. Young Request to Testify – San Antonio	12/03/08	26 & 56	12/04/08
08-CV-075		Mark Hammons	12/08/08	56	12/08/08
08-CV-076	08-CV-149 Testimony	Honorable H. Russel Holland Request to Testify – San Francisco	12/08/08	56	12/08/08
08-CV-077		Honorable G. Patrick Murphy Request to Testify – San Antonio	12/09/08	26 & 56	12/10/08
08-CV-078	08-CV-137 Testimony	Mary Massaron Ross Request to Testify – San Francisco	12/11/08	56	12/11/08
08-CV-079	08-CV-117 Testimony	DRI – The Voice of the Defense Bar (Cary E. Hiltgen) Request to Testify – San Antonio	12/11/08	26 & 56	12/12/08
08-CV-080	08-CV-112 Testimony	Charles Miers Request to Testify – San Antonio	12/12/08	26	12/15/08
08-CV-081	08-CV-116 Testimony	Texas Association of Defense Counsel (Keith B. O’Connell) Request to Testify – San Antonio	12/12/08	26 & 56	12/15/08
08-CV-082		Robert S. Mantell	12/12/08	56	12/15/08
08-CV-083	08-CV-142 Testimony	Honorable David F. Hamilton Request to Testify – San Francisco	12/15/08	56	12/15/08
08-CV-084		U.S. Department of Justice – Drug Enforcement Administration (Wendy H. Goggin)	11/19/08	26	12/15/08
08-CV-085		Stephen Pate Request to Testify – San Antonio	12/15/08	26 & 56	12/18/08
08-CV-086	08-CV-156 Testimony	Brian Sanford Request to Testify – San Antonio	12/15/08	56	12/18/08
08-CV-087	08-CV-119 Testimony	Advocacy, Inc. (Thomas J. Crane) Request to Testify – San Antonio	12/15/08	56	12/18/08
08-CV-088	08-CV-118 Testimony	Malinda A. Gaul Request to Testify – San Antonio	12/15/08	56	12/18/08
08-CV-089	08-CV-157 Testimony	Margie A. Harris Request to Testify – San Antonio	12/15/08	56	12/18/08
08-CV-090	08-CV-155 Testimony	All Active, Senior, and Magistrate Judges, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California (Honorable Claudia Wilken) Request to Testify – San Francisco	12/16/08	56	12/18/08
08-CV-091		Deborah Kuchler (replacing Sarah Iiams) Request to Testify – San Antonio	12/16/08	56	12/18/08
08-CV-092	08-CV-136 Testimony	Andrew B. Downs Request to Testify – San Francisco	12/16/08	26 & 56	12/18/08
08-CV-093	08-CV-111 Testimony	Carlos Rincon Request to Testify – San Antonio	12/17/08	26 & 56	12/18/08
08-CV-094	08-CV-167 Testimony	Federation of Defense and Corporate Counsel (Michael T. Lucey) Request to Testify – San Francisco	12/17/08	26 & 56	12/18/08
08-CV-095		Kevin J. Dunne Request to Testify – San Francisco	12/18/08	26 & 56	12/22/08
08-CV-096		Michele Y. Smith Request to Testify – San Antonio	12/18/08	56	12/22/08
08-CV-097	08-CV-135 Testimony	DRI - Voice of the Defense Bar (Marc E. Williams) Request to Testify – San Francisco	12/22/08	26 & 56	12/24/08
08-CV-098		Committee on Civil Litigation of the US District Court in the Eastern District of New York (Guy Miller Struve)	12/22/08	26 & 56	12/24/08
08-CV-099	08-CV-138 Testimony	State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company (Jeffrey W. Jackson) Request to Testify – San Francisco	12/23/08	56	12/24/08
08-CV-100		National Employment Lawyers Association (L. Steven Platt)	12/29/08	56	12/31/08
08-CV-101	08-CV-127 Testimony	Michael R. Nelson Request to Testify – San Francisco	12/29/08	56	12/31/08
08-CV-102	08-CV-152 Testimony	American Bar Association – Section of Litigation (Jeffrey J. Greenbaum and Loren Kieve) Request to Testify – San Francisco	01/05/09	26 & 56	01/05/09
08-CV-103	08-CV-133 Testimony	Sharon J. Arkin Request to Testify – San Francisco	01/05/09	56	01/05/09
08-CV-104		District and Magistrate Judges of United States District Court of Indiana (Honorable Robert L. Miller, Jr.)	01/06/09	26 & 56	01/13/09
08-CV-105	08-CV-154 Testimony 08-CV-153 Reference	The Association of the Federal Bar of New Jersey (Peter S. Pearlman) Request to Testify – San Francisco	01/06/09	26	01/13/09
08-CV-106	08-CV-150 Testimony	Elizabeth J. Cabraser Request to Testify – San Francisco	01/06/09	26 & 56	01/13/09
08-CV-107	08-CV-140 Testimony	Donald Fritz Zimmer Request to Testify – San Francisco	01/06/09	26 & 56	01/13/09
08-CV-108	08-CV-126 Cancellation	Lawyers for Civil Justice (Gregory M. Lederer) Request to Testify – San Francisco	01/07/09	56	01/13/09
08-CV-109		Seven Massachusetts Lawyers (Ellen J. Messing)	01/05/09	56	01/13/09
08-CV-110	08-CV-065 Request	Shell Oil Company (G. Edward Pickle)	01/06/09	26 & 56	blank
08-CV-111	08-CV-093 Request	Carlos Rincon	01/07/09	56	blank
08-CV-112	08-CV-080 Request	Charles Miers	01/07/09	26	blank
08-CV-113	08-CV-058 Request	DRI – The Voice of the Defense Bar (John H. Martin)	01/07/09	26 & 56	blank
08-CV-114		Alaska Chapter of the Federal Bar Association (Gregory S. Fisher)	01/07/09	56	01/13/09
08-CV-115		Professor Stephen D. Easton Request to Testify – San Francisco	01/06/09	26	01/13/09
08-CV-116	08-CV-081 Request	Texas Association of Defense Counsel (Keith B. O’Connell)	01/07/09	26 & 56	blank
08-CV-117	08-CV-079 Request	DRI – The Voice of the Defense Bar (Cary E. Hiltgen)	01/07/09	26 & 56	blank
08-CV-118	08-CV-088 Request	Malinda A. Gaul	01/07/09	56	blank
08-CV-119	08-CV-087 Request	Advocacy Incorporated (Thomas J. Crane)	01/07/09	56	blank
08-CV-120	blank	Judges of the District of Alaska (Honorable John W. Sedwick)	01/09/09	56	01/13/09
08-CV-121	blank	Fellows of the American College of Trial Lawyers (Phil R. Richards)	01/06/09	26 & 56	01/13/09
08-CV-122	blank	Peter O. Glaessner Request to Testify – San Francisco	01/07/09	26 & 56	01/13/09
08-CV-123	blank	Honorable Barbara B. Crabb	01/09/09	56	01/13/09
08-CV-124	08-CV-019 Request	Federation of Defense and Corporate Counsel (Wayne B. Mason)	01/12/09	26 & 56	blank
08-CV-125	blank	Raoul D. Kennedy Request to Testify – San Francisco	01/20/09	26 & 56	blank
08-CV-126	08-CV-108 Request	Lawyers for Civil Justice (Gregory M. Lederer) Cancelled Testimony	01/22/09	56	blank
08-CV-127	08-CV-101 Request	Michael R. Nelson	01/23/09	56	blank
08-CV-128	blank	The Council of the Section of Litigation, ABA (Robert L. Rothman)	01/23/09	26	01/26/09
08-CV-129	08-CV-068 Request	Daniel J. Herling	01/26/09	26 & 56	blank
08-CV-130	08-CV-069 Request	District and Magistrate Judges of the Western District of Washington (Honorable Robert S. Lasnik)	01/26/09	56	blank
08-CV-131	blank	Commercial and Federal Litigation Section of the New York State Bar Association (Gregory K. Arenson)	01/26/09	56	01/26/09
08-CV-132	blank	Honorable Timothy J. Savage	01/26/09	56	01/26/09
08-CV-133	08-CV-103 Request	Sharon J. Arkin	01/26/09	56	blank
08-CV-134	blank	Professor Bradley Scott Shannon	01/26/09	56	01/29/09
08-CV-135	08-CV-097 Request	DRI - Voice of the Defense Bar (Marc E. Williams)	01/27/09	26 & 56	blank
08-CV-136	08-CV-092 Request	Andrew B. Downs	01/27/09	56	blank
08-CV-137	08-CV-078 Request	Mary Massaron Ross	01/27/09	56	blank
08-CV-138	08-CV-099 Request	State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company (Jeffrey W. Jackson)	01/27/09	56	blank
08-CV-139	08-CV-063 Request	Voice of the Defense Bar (Kimberly D. Baker)	01/27/09	26 & 56	blank
08-CV-140	08-CV-107 Request	Donald Fritz Zimmer	01/27/09	26 & 56	blank
08-CV-141	08-CV-143 Testimony	National Employment Lawyers Association (Stefano G. Moscato) Request to Testify – San Francisco	01/27/09	56	blank
08-CV-142	08-CV-083 Request	Honorable David F. Hamilton	01/27/09	56	blank
08-CV-143	08-CV-141 Request	National Employment Lawyers Association (Stefano G. Moscato)	01/28/09	56	blank
08-CV-144	08-CV-067 Request	Ralph A. Zappala	01/28/09	26 & 56	blank
08-CV-145	blank	Professor Stephen B. Burbank	01/28/09	56	01/29/09
08-CV-146	blank	Mark A. Buchanan	01/28/09	56	01/29/09
08-CV-147	blank	Gene P. Graham	01/28/09	56	01/29/09
08-CV-148	08-CV-073 Request	Thomas A. Packer	01/28/09	26 & 56	blank
08-CV-149	08-CV-076 Request	Honorable H. Russel Holland	01/29/09	56	blank
08-CV-150	08-CV-106 Request	Public Justice and the Public Justice Foundation (Elizabeth J. Cabraser)	01/29/09	26 & 56	blank
08-CV-151	blank	Joan Herrington	01/30/09	26 & 56	02/02/09
08-CV-152	08-CV-102 Request	American Bar Association – Section of Litigation (Jeffrey J. Greenbaum)	01/30/09	56	blank
08-CV-153	blank	Trustees of the Association of the Federal Bar of New Jersey (Dennis J. Drasco)	01/30/09	26	02/02/09
08-CV-154	08-CV-105 Request 08-CV-153 Reference	Rules Committee of the Association of the Federal Bar of New Jersey (Peter S. Pearlman)	01/30/09	26	blank
08-CV-155	08-CV-090 Request	All Active, Senior, and Magistrate Judges, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California (Honorable Claudia Wilken)	02/05/09	56	blank
08-CV-156	08-CV-086 Request	Brian P. Sanford	02/06/09	56	blank
08-CV-157	08-CV-089 Request	Margaret A. Harris	02/06/09	56	blank
08-CV-158	blank	Professor Suja A. Thomas	02/09/09	56	02/09/09
08-CV-159	blank	John A. K. Grunert	02/09/09	26	02/09/09
08-CV-160	blank	Professor Stephen N. Subrin	02/09/09	56	02/09/09
08-CV-161	blank	Federal Magistrate Judges Association (Honorable Anthony J. Battaglia)	02/10/09	26 & 56	02/167/09
08-CV-162	blank	Honorable Michael R. Merz, J. Steven Justice, Lynnette Dinkler, and Donald E. Burton of The Federal Practice Committee of The Dayton Bar Association	02/10/09	56	02/17/09
08-CV-163	08-CV-069 Reference	Perkins Coie LLP (Harry H. Schneider)	02/11/09	56	02/13/09
08-CV-164	blank	Honorable Janice M. Stewart	02/12/09	56	02/13/09
08-CV-165	blank	Scott Jerger, Stephen W. Manning, Danielle J. Hunsaker, and Karen O’Kasey of the Oregon State Bar	02/13/09	56	02/17/09
08-CV-166	blank	United States District Court for the District of Oregon (Honorable Sue L. Robinson, Honorable Gregory M. Sleet, and Honorable Joseph J. Farnan, Jr.)	02/13/09	56	02/17/09
08-CV-167	08-CV-094 Request	Federation of Corporate and Defense Counsel (Michael T. Lucey)	02/13/09	26 & 56	02/17/09
08-CV-168	blank	Cynthia L. Pollick	02/17/09	56	02/18/09
08-CV-169	blank	Professor Stephen D. Easton	02/17/09	26	02/18/09
08-CV-170	blank	Karen K. Fitzgerald	02/17/09	56	02/19/09
08-CV-171	blank	N. Sue Allen	02/17/09	56	02/19/09
08-CV-172	blank	David L. Wiley, Member, National Employment Lawyers Association	02/17/09	56	02/19/09
08-CV-173	blank	New York City Bar Association (Wendy H. Schwartz)	02/17/09	56	02/19/09
08-CV-174	blank	Federal Bar Council (Robert J. Giuffra)	02/17/09	26 & 56	02/19/09
08-CV-175	blank	Honorable Marcia S. Krieger	02/17/09	56	02/19/09
08-CV-176	blank	State Bar of California’s Committee on Administration of Justice (Reuben A. Ginsburg)	02/17/09	26 & 56	02/19/09
08-CV-177	blank	Paul R. Harris, Member, National Employment Lawyers Association	02/17/09	56	02/19/09
08-CV-178	blank	Alice W. Ballard	02/17/09	56	02/19/09
08-CV-179	blank	Robert J. Wiley	02/17/09	56	02/19/09
08-CV-180	blank	U.S. Department of Justice Civil Division (Honorable Michael F. Hertz, Acting Assistant Attorney General)	02/17/09	26 & 56	02/19/09
08-CV-181	blank	Lawyers for Civil Justice and the U.S. Chamber Institute for Legal Reform (Barry Bauman)	02/17/09	26 & 56	02/19/09
08-CV-182	blank	Amy E. Gibson	02/17/09	56	02/19/09
08-CV-183	blank	Professor Eric Schnapper	02/17/09	56	02/19/09
08-CV-184	blank	United States Courts Committee of the State Bar of Michigan (Thaddeus E. Morgan)	02/18/09	26	02/19/09
08-CV-185	blank	The American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (Patrice Schiano, Thomas E. Hilton, and Teighlor Simon March)	02/20/09	26	02/24/09
08-CV-186	blank	Allen D. Black	02/23/09	56	02/24/09
08-CV-187	blank	Honorable Rebecca Beach Smith	02/24/09	56	02/24/09
08-CV-188	blank	Honorable Leonie M. Brinkema	02/27/09	56	03/02/09
08-CV-189	blank	Federal Bar Association of the Western District of Washington (Stuart R. Dunwoody)	02/27/09	56	03/02/09
08-CV-190	blank	Honorable Robert E. Payne	02/27/09	56	03/02/09
08-CV-191	blank	National Association of Consumer Advocates (James C. Sturdevant)	03/10/09	56	03/11/09
08-CV-192	blank	Conference of Chief Bankruptcy Judges of the Ninth Circuit (Honorable Robert J. Faris)	03/25/09	56	03/31/09