Main content

Novogroder v. NOM Lima Shawnee LLC

Case Summary: 07-cv-1284

On March 30, 2007, plaintiff George Novogroder filed a verified complaint for injunction, specific performance, declaratory judgment, and breach of contract against defendant NOM Lima Shawnee LLC in the Allen County, Ohio Court of Common Pleas, which was removed to the United States District Court for the Northern District of Ohio on the basis of federal diversity jurisdiction. The complaint alleged that plaintiff and defendant entered into a contract for the sale of property and that defendant, the owner of the property, breached the contract by notifying plaintiff that it would not sell the property to him. Defendant denied the allegations and filed counterclaims for slander of title, intentional interference with business relationships, and quiet title.

Prior to the filing of plaintiff's complaint, defendant had filed a suit in an Alabama state court. The federal district court stayed plaintiff's action, permitting the Alabama suit to proceed first. The Alabama court held, in a final and binding judgment, that the parties did not have a contract for the sale and purchase of the property. As such, all of plaintiff's claims and defendant's claim for quiet title were precluded.

A jury trial was held from November 15, 2011 through November 18, 2011 on defendant's counterclaims for slander of title and intentional interference with business relationships. The jury returned a verdict on November 18, 2011, finding in favor of plaintiff. The court entered judgment on November 29, 2011.

Case Highlights

  • Notice of Removal from Allen County [Doc # 1]
  • Answer [Doc #5]
  • Jury Trial Held on 11/15/2011-11/18/2011
  • Jury verdict: redacted on 11/18/2012
    • In favor of plaintiff Novogroder
  • Judgment Entry [Doc # 160]
    • Does not include substance of opinions or verdict

Case-related documents, including those referenced above, are available via the Public Access to Court Electronic Records (PACER) service. For more information, visit Pacer.gov.

Videos from this Case:

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 6) NEW
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 6) NEW

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 6) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, 11/16/2011, 9:55 AM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L.Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 7)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 7)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 7) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/16/2011, 10:30 PM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 8)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 8)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 8) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/16/2011, 11:30 PM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 9)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 9)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 9) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/16/2011, 11:30 PM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 10)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 10)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 10) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/16/2011, 2:06 PM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 11)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 11)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 11) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/16/2011, 2:30 PM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 12)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 12)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 12) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/16/2011, 2:30 PM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 13)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 13)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 13) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/16/2011, 4:00 PM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 14)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 14)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 14) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/16/2011, 4:10 PM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 15)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 15)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 15) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/16/2011, 4:17 PM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 16)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 16)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 16) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/16/2011, 4:25 PM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 17)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 17)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 17) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/16/2011, 4:30 PM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 18)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 18)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 18) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/17/2011, 11:00 AM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 19)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 19)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 19) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/17/2011, 11:22 PM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 20)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 20)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 20) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/17/2011, 12:13 AM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 21)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 21)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 21) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/17/2011, 12:20 AM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 22)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 22)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 22) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/17/2011, 1:40 PM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L.Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 23)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 23)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 23) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/17/2011, 3:10 PM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video

OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 24)
Thumbnail for OHN- Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 24)

Novogroder V. NOM Lima Shawnee (Part 24) Case: 3:07-CV-1284, Breach of Contract Case, 11/18/2011, 11:50 AM (EDT). James M. Ashley and Thomas W.L. Ashley US Courthouse. Judge James G. Carr presiding.


Click to Play Video